Last Friday, the government asked the Supreme Court to review the Sixth Circuit’s decision in United States v. Quality Stores. In that decision, the Sixth Circuit sided with taxpayers and concluded that certain severance payments that qualify as supplemental unemployment compensation benefit payments (or “SUB” payments) for federal income tax
Continue Reading U.S. Seeks Supreme Court Review of Decision that Severance Pay for Layoffs Is Not Subject to FICA Tax
Robert Newman
Robert Newman is a partner in the firm’s employee benefits and executive compensation practice group. He represents clients ranging from small employers to some of the nation's largest employers, including for-profit and tax-exempt entities. His practice includes:
designing, drafting, and amending a wide range of retirement plans (including 401(k) plans, ESOPs, and traditional and hybrid defined benefit plans) and welfare plans (including health, severance, and cafeteria plans);
creating executive compensation arrangements including nonqualified deferred compensation plans, stock option plans, and other incentive plans;
representing clients before the IRS and the Department of Labor;
assisting clients with legislative initiatives;
providing benefits expertise in corporate transactions and ERISA litigation;
counseling clients with respect to pension fund investments in private equity funds and hedge funds; and
negotiating and writing employment agreements.
Chambers USA ranks Robert as Band 1 for Employee Benefits & Executive Compensation, citing client interviews describing him as "an excellent lawyer and a great problem solver," and "extremely knowledgeable, thoughtful and thorough," while commending his "wealth of experience handling pension derisking transactions as well as a proven ability to handle litigious matters."
Two Recent Reports Indicate Some Optimism Regarding Health Care Costs
Two recently released reports indicate that the cost of healthcare will not increase as much as previously expected. Milliman recently issued the 2013 Milliman Medical Index, showing that the total annual cost of healthcare for a typical family of four covered by an employer-provided plan increased in 2013 by…
Continue Reading Two Recent Reports Indicate Some Optimism Regarding Health Care Costs
ACA’s Employer Mandate in a Single Graphic
The Affordable Care Act’s “pay or play” mandate goes into effect starting in 2014. Under the mandate, large employers (employers with 50 or more full-time employees) must either provide health coverage to their employees or pay an excise tax. The chart below shows when the “pay or play” penalty applies…
Continue Reading ACA’s Employer Mandate in a Single Graphic
Employers Continue to Prevail in Stock Drop Litigation
The Seventh Circuit’s recent decision in White v. Marshall & Ilsley Corp. awarded another early-round victory to employers in ERISA stock-drop litigation.
The plaintiffs in this case sought to recover losses in the M&I Bank 401(k) Plan’s stock fund that were attributable to a 54% decline in the market price of M&I stock that occurred during the financial crisis of 2008 and 2009. The district court granted M&I’s motion to dismiss the plaintiffs’ misrepresentation and imprudent investment claims, but the plaintiffs appealed only the dismissal of their imprudent investment claims.
The Seventh Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment. Consistent with rulings by the Second, Third, and Eleventh Circuit (and contrary to a ruling by the Sixth Circuit), the Court ruled that the presumption of prudence adopted by the Third Circuit in Moench v. Robertson, 62 F.3d 553 (3d Cir. 1995) applied at the pleading stage as a substantive standard of conduct and that the presumption was not an evidentiary standard to be applied at the summary judgment stage, as urged by the plaintiffs and their amicus, the Secretary of Labor.
Continue Reading Employers Continue to Prevail in Stock Drop Litigation
2014 Administration Proposal Would Eliminate ESOP Dividend Deduction
The Obama Administration’s 2014 budget includes a proposal to eliminate the deduction for dividends paid on employer stock held by an employee stock ownership plan (“ESOP”). The proposal would be effective for dividends paid after the date the budget is enacted. Under the proposal, the deduction would continue to be…
Continue Reading 2014 Administration Proposal Would Eliminate ESOP Dividend Deduction
Supreme Court’s McCutchen Decision Highlights Plan Drafting Opportunity
In its recent decision in U.S. Airways v. McCutchen, all nine justices of the Supreme Court agreed that equitable principles do not override the clear terms of an ERISA plan. Although a majority of the Court went on to find that the plan at issue was ambiguous, the decision makes clear that plan documents—when clear—may fill in gaps in areas that ERISA does not prescribe. Employers may wish to address several of these areas in plan documents. The McCutchen case shows that identifying these areas and drafting clear plan language can help achieve the plan sponsor’s objectives.
Continue Reading Supreme Court’s McCutchen Decision Highlights Plan Drafting Opportunity
5 Privacy and Data Security Measures That Can Protect Your Company Against Trade Secret Theft by Employees
As we have previously discussed, companies face a growing threat that trade secrets and other critical business information will be taken by employees and other insiders. Protecting business critical information is not simple. Companies need a holistic approach that implicates multiple areas of the law, including data security, privacy,…
Continue Reading 5 Privacy and Data Security Measures That Can Protect Your Company Against Trade Secret Theft by Employees
While the Supreme Court considers DOMA’s fate, what’s an in-house benefits lawyer or HR professional to do?
If the Supreme Court holds that the Defense of Marriage Act (“DOMA”) is unconstitutional, those involved with the administration of employee benefits plans will be very busy. Under DOMA, a benefit plan is not required to recognize same-sex marriage and, in many cases, must treat same-sex spouses differently than opposite-sex spouses. If DOMA is struck down, employers might need to amend their benefit plans, and plan administration will necessarily change. Many changes will need to be implemented quickly.
Continue Reading While the Supreme Court considers DOMA’s fate, what’s an in-house benefits lawyer or HR professional to do?
Why Is a Benefits Lawyer Talking about Trade Secret Theft?
At a recent forum in New York, a team of Covington & Burling LLP lawyers addressed the growing concern among companies that their most valuable assets might just walk out the front door on a thumb drive in an employee’s pocket or otherwise be taken by company insiders. Although much of the discussion in this country is focused on securing systems from cyber-attacks, Michael Chertoff (former Secretary of Homeland Security and now Senior Of Counsel at Covington) noted that focusing only on attacks from outside a company is like locking a door but leaving a window open. The threat from insiders is substantial, and addressing this threat involves many disciplines, including employee benefits and executive compensation.
Protecting business critical information is not simple. It involves identifying which information is critical, designating that information confidential, establishing practices, procedures, and policies to maintain confidentiality, and being prepared to address immediately breaches that occur. Each step implicates several areas of the law, including data security, privacy, intellectual property, white collar crime, employment, employee benefits and executive compensation, corporate and securities, insurance coverage, and crisis management. For example, the recent White House initiative to combat trade secret theft identified human resources policies as a key area of focus in developing best practices to protect trade secrets.
Continue Reading Why Is a Benefits Lawyer Talking about Trade Secret Theft?
Plan Fiduciaries Might Need to File a Notice to Avoid Registration Requirements as Commodity Pool Operators
Several changes to the definition of “commodity pool operator” could require fiduciaries of retirement plans to file for an exemption from treatment as a “commodity pool operator,” or be subject to comprehensive registration and compliance requirements. A “commodity pool operator” is generally a manager of a pooled investment vehicle that invests in commodity interests. The Dodd-Frank Act amended the Commodity Exchange Act to include swaps within the commodity interests that will establish a commodity pool. Investment in futures and options on futures also will cause a pooled investment vehicle to be considered a commodity pool. A plan fiduciary could therefore be treated as a “commodity pool operator” if the plan invests in swaps, futures or options on futures, or invests in a fund that, directly or indirectly, invests in those commodity interests. Several exemptions may apply. However, some exemptions require a filing with the National Futures Association, and recent guidance from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) requires the exemption filing in more circumstances than before.
Continue Reading Plan Fiduciaries Might Need to File a Notice to Avoid Registration Requirements as Commodity Pool Operators